Putting Exams to the Test

Date: Monday 1 October 2012, 6:30pm (for 7pm start) to 8:30pm

Venue: White Cloth Gallery, 24-26 Aire Street, Leeds, LS1 4HT (near the back of Leeds Station)

Admission: Tickets are £5/£3 concessions. Book in advance through this Eventbrite link, or pay at the venue on the night.

Speakers: Dennis HayesAudrey Osler and Valerie Farnsworth


As part of the Battle of Ideas 2012 festival of debate, Leeds Salon is hosting a satellite event on the theme of education.

Every year we see an increase in the number of pupils achieving top grades in GCSEs and A-levels. And every year this sparks a row about standards in education. While some argue that improving results show pupils are getting smarter and working harder, others raise questions about the quality of examinations and school curricula. Many educationalists and commentators argue we have seen a long and steady dumbing-down in educational standards, in which traditional subjects have lost rigour, to be replaced by modular courses with multiple re-sits or by vocational qualifications; while exam boards have been accused of being complicit in competing to offer easier courses, and schools in shopping round for exams that will improve their league table results.

To tackle what he sees as this 'culture of competitive dumbing-down', education secretary Michael Gove plans to replace GCSEs in England from 2014 with a 'tougher' O-level style system alongside a simpler exam for less academic teenagers, like the old CSE. This has provoked charges of 'elitism' and re-creating a 'two-tier' education system in which poorer students will be fobbed-off with a second class education. Others argue this shows ignorance of the current exam system within which those deemed less capable are already directed down the path of lower level GCSEs and NVQs. In addition, many private schools already opt for the International GCE (comparable to the old O-level), while increasing numbers of state schools and sixth-form colleges are turning to a baccalaureate system, also favoured by Gove, as a 'stable' and 'safer alternative' to grade inflation with A-levels.

So, would the return to 'O' levels create a two-tier and elitist system in education that confines many to the scrapheap? Or is it a step in the right direction to improving academic standards for all? What purpose do exams serve anyway? Are they the best way to assess pupils’ abilities, and an important part of what education should be about? Or do they discriminate unfairly against less academic pupils?


The Battle of Ideas 2012 is two days of high-level, though-provoking, public debate organised by the Institute of Ideas, and held on Saturday 20th & Sunday 21st October at the Barbican, London. The Battle of Ideas festival comprises 75 debates and satellite discussion confronting society’s big issues and unresolved questions. It affords the opportunity for some clear thinking, rational debate and agenda-setting. For more information and tickets visit the Battle of Ideas website here.



Q&A: GCSE shake-up, BBC, 17 September 2012

Plans for O-level-style exams to replace GCSEs, Angela Harrison, BBC, 21 June 2012

British education is already a vale of tiers, Tom Finn-Kelcy, spiked, 26 June 2012

Who’s backing the International Bac? Fiona Holmer, BBC Learning Parents Blog, 3 June 2012

Exams need ‘fundamental reform’, MPs say, Hannah Richardson, BBC, 3 July 2012

GCSE ward: the case for real hard exams, Frank Furedi, spiked, 28 August 2012

Time for a Good Old-Fashioned Debate on Education, Dennis Hayes, Huffington Post, 25 September 2012


Leeds Salon on Facebook

Follow theleedssalon on Twitter

Sign up to our mailing list


The Leeds Salon is a judging partner of the sixth form Debating Matters competition

The Tetley and The Leeds Salon are partners in school debate for central and south Leeds

The HFoI and The Leeds Salon are partners in school debate for north Leeds


Leeds Salon is a member of the Amazon Affiliate Programme. When you follow this link, we receive a small percentage of anything you spend in that visit. It costs you no extra but is a big help to us!

Leeds Debate Links

Arts Society Leeds

Café Psychologique

Café Scientifique (Chapel Allerton)

Café Scientifique (Headingley)

FORUM 2000

Headingley Festival of Ideas

Headingley LitFest

Leeds Library Salon

Leeds Phil & Lit Society

Leeds Pint of Science

Taking Soundings

Talking Allowed In Leeds: PiPs

Think Headingley: PiPs


National Debate Links

Salon Aberystwyth

Birmingham Salon

East Midlands Salon

Exeter Salon

Liverpool Salon

London Legal Salon

Manchester Salon

Academy of Ideas

Debating Matters

Manifesto Club


The Great Debate



Global Debate Links

Berlin Salon

Dublin Salon

Zurich Salon


Donations gratefully received