What Welfare State Do We Want?

Date: Monday 4 April 2016, 6:45pm (for 7pm start) to 8:30pm

Venue: Carriageworks Theatre, Room 1

Speakers: Ruth Patrick, Andrew Dunn

£5 waged/£4 unwaged to pay on the door. To reserve a place, please e-mail us at contact@leedssalon.org.uk

Once celebrated as a keystone of post-war Britain, the welfare state is today accused of fostering a ‘dependency culture’ that traps people on benefits and encourages ‘intergenerational worklessness’. Successive governments have sought to address this through a broad programme of welfare reform, including changes to welfare-to-work schemes, cuts in the real value of many benefits, and increasing conditions placed on the receipt of welfare. However, is this the best way of tackling the problem? And is the discussion about ‘welfare dependency’ entirely the right one?

The original notion of welfare was as a ‘safety net’ to help people cope with hardship, and return them to a situation of independence as soon as possible. In other words, it was premised on a view of people as capable. Today, however, out-of-work welfare provision seems to start from either an assumption of general incapacity, or that claimants are passive dependents who require tough measures to get them back to work. But does the notion of ‘dependency’, and widely held assumptions about welfare claimants cynically manipulating the system, actually miss the extent to which individuals have been encouraged to view themselves as in need of state assistance, as well as the realities of unemployment and poverty?

Shouldn’t the welfare system simply help people to live as independently as possible, rather than impose conditions on those claiming benefits and blame them for their predicament? Or is there a moral imperative to reform welfare? And, if so, how do we protect those who are genuinely dependent and in need of state support? Ultimately, what kinds of social provision do we want in society?



The realities of living on welfare are significantly different from government and media characterisations, Ruth Patrick, LSE, 5 January 2015

Andrew Dunn: My new research that challenges the left-wing consensus about jobless people and work, ConservtibeHome, 12 Janury 2015

Poverty porn and the war on welfare, Tracey Jensen, Social Action & Research Foundation, 12 November 2014

Exposed: The myth of a 'culture of worklessness', Robert Macdonald & Tracy Shildrick, Guardian, 14 December 2012

What's so great about the welfare state? James Panton, Spiked, 21 April 2010


Leeds Salon on Facebook

Follow theleedssalon on Twitter

Sign up to our mailing list


The Leeds Salon is a judging partner of the sixth form Debating Matters competition

The Tetley and The Leeds Salon are partners in school debate for central and south Leeds

The HFoI and The Leeds Salon are partners in school debate for north Leeds


Leeds Salon is a member of the Amazon Affiliate Programme. When you follow this link, we receive a small percentage of anything you spend in that visit. It costs you no extra but is a big help to us!

Leeds Debate Links

Arts Society Leeds

Café Psychologique

Café Scientifique (Chapel Allerton)

Café Scientifique (Headingley)

FORUM 2000

Headingley Festival of Ideas

Headingley LitFest

Leeds Library Salon

Leeds Phil & Lit Society

Leeds Pint of Science

Taking Soundings

Talking Allowed In Leeds: PiPs

Think Headingley: PiPs


National Debate Links

Salon Aberystwyth

Birmingham Salon

East Midlands Salon

Exeter Salon

Liverpool Salon

London Legal Salon

Manchester Salon

Academy of Ideas

Debating Matters

Manifesto Club


The Great Debate



Global Debate Links

Berlin Salon

Dublin Salon

Zurich Salon


Donations gratefully received